Skip to content

From the press

How we check every puzzle before print

By Pecan Hill Press · · 4 min read

A bookshelf with the cover of an escape room advent calendar from Pecan Hill Press

A puzzle book has a problem that a novel doesn’t. If one sentence in a novel is clumsy, you read past it. If one puzzle in a puzzle book has no solution — or two — the reader is stuck, and the book has let them down at exactly the moment they were enjoying it most.

So before any of our puzzle books goes to print, it goes through a set of checks. Some are about the puzzles themselves, some about whether the printed page is comfortable to read, and some about whether the book delivers what its cover promises. This note explains what we check and why.

1. Every answer is checked from scratch

Each puzzle is created together with its intended solution. That’s not enough on its own: the person (or program) who made a puzzle is the worst judge of whether it works, because they already know the answer.

So every grid puzzle is checked again by a separate solver that starts from a blank page:

  • Sudoku: the solution must be valid, must match the given numbers, and must be the only solution.
  • Word search: every word on the list must appear in the grid exactly once, and the marked solution must match that single position.
  • Logic grids: the clues must lead to exactly one arrangement, and it must be the one in the answer key.
  • Ciphers and locks: decoding the message must give the stated answer, and a combination lock must have exactly one code.

For story-based escape-room books, we check that each day resolves to exactly one code.

If any check fails, the puzzle is rebuilt — not patched with a note in the answer key.

2. Readability is measured on the print file

How big text looks on a screen tells you very little about how it will read on paper. A caption that looks fine at full-screen zoom can turn out to be tiny in print. So we measure text sizes on the actual print-ready PDF, not on a preview.

Our minimums for puzzle books:

  • text you need to read to solve a puzzle: 12 pt or larger;
  • labels and captions inside drawings and maps: 10 pt or larger;
  • lines you need to see to solve a puzzle (grid lines, paths on a map): at least 1 pt thick;
  • no grey text for anything that matters.

If we ever describe a book as large print, everything in it has to measure 16 pt or more. Fourteen point isn’t large print, however generous it looks.

We also check that every font is properly embedded in the file, so nothing gets swapped or misprinted at the printer.

3. The whole book is reviewed page by page

Once the book is laid out, every page of the final PDF is rendered as an image and reviewed in order, the way a reader would meet it. Pages are looked at for value, fun, variety, atmosphere and finish. Technical pages like the title page or answer pages are reviewed separately, so they don’t hide weak content pages.

If too many pages fall short, the book goes back for another pass. The goal is a book we would be glad to hand to a friend, not one that merely passes a checklist.

4. The cover’s promise is checked against the inside

Book covers make claims: a number of days, a number of puzzles, “solutions included”, a page size. Each of these is checked against the finished file. If a subtitle says something like “24 days”, there must be 24 days inside. If it says solutions are included, the solution pages must be there.

We also look at the first pages of the book on their own — roughly what you’d see in an online preview. A reader should meet real content early, not ten pages of front matter.

5. What we don’t claim

Checks catch a lot, but not everything. A puzzle can be correct and still not be fun; a clue can be fair and still feel too obscure. That’s why we welcome honest feedback — good, bad or in between — and why we offer free review copies to reviewers with no conditions on what they write.

Where to see the result

Our mysteries are published under our Ink & Clue imprint, which keeps a few puzzles from each book free to play online. You can try them on inkandclue.com and see for yourself whether the checks paid off.

For how we approach colouring books, read why our coloring pages use thick lines and large print.

More from the press